The Perfect Story Bakery menu

Our Menu

Every treat is handcrafted to order with love and the finest ingredients.

Cakes

Custom cakes made to order in a variety of sizes and shapes. All cakes include your choice of flavor and filling.

✦

Cakes are not available for direct purchase online. Every cake is custom — please fill out our order form so we can bring your vision to life! Submit your order here →

Bento 4"

Starting at $25

A petite personal cake perfect for solo celebrations, smash cakes, or a sweet gift. Fully customizable with your choice of flavor, filling, and design.

6" Circle

Starting at $60

A classic round cake serving approximately 8–10 guests. Great for intimate birthdays, anniversaries, and small gatherings.

8" Circle

Starting at $80

Our most popular size, serving approximately 12–16 guests. Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, and celebrations of all kinds.

10" Circle

Starting at $100

A generous round cake serving approximately 20–25 guests. Ideal for larger parties and events.

12" Circle

Starting at $140

A statement cake serving approximately 30–35 guests. Perfect for big milestones and large family gatherings.

1/4 Sheet

Starting at $100

A classic sheet cake serving approximately 24 guests. Great for office parties, school events, and casual celebrations.

1/2 Sheet

Starting at $170

A half sheet cake serving approximately 48 guests. A crowd-pleaser for large parties and community events.

Full Sheet

Starting at $260

Our largest sheet cake, serving approximately 96 guests. Perfect for weddings, quinceañeras, and large-scale events.

6" Heart

Starting at $70

A charming heart-shaped cake serving approximately 8–10 guests. A romantic choice for anniversaries, Valentine's Day, and love-filled celebrations.

8" Heart

Starting at $90

A heart-shaped cake serving approximately 12–16 guests. Beautiful for bridal showers, engagements, and special occasions.

10" Heart

Starting at $125

A large heart-shaped cake serving approximately 20–25 guests. Make a grand gesture at your next celebration.

8" Tiramisu

Starting at $140

A classic Italian tiramisu in an 8" round — layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream, dusted with cocoa. No bake, all indulgence.

Loaf Cake

Starting at $25

A moist, sliceable loaf cake perfect for gifting or enjoying at home. Ask us about our current available flavors — they rotate seasonally!

Pastries & Desserts

Freshly made pastries, dessert cups, and indulgent treats baked from scratch for every occasion.

✦

Pastries & Desserts are not available for direct purchase online. Please fill out our order form and we'll get your order started! Submit your order here →

Dozen Cupcakes

$25

Twelve full-size cupcakes with your choice of cake flavor and frosting. Customizable with toppers, sprinkles, and themed decorations.

Dozen Mini Cupcakes

$25

Twelve bite-size mini cupcakes — perfect for party favors, dessert tables, or when you want a little taste of everything.

Cakescicles

$35

Cake on a stick, dipped in smooth chocolate and decorated to match your theme. A fun, handheld treat guests will love.

Chocolate Dipped Treats

Starting at $25

Strawberries, Oreos, pretzels, and more dipped in rich chocolate and decorated to order. A crowd favorite for any event. Prices may vary by item and quantity.

Brownies

$15

Dense, fudgy chocolate brownies baked fresh to order. Rich, chewy, and impossible to eat just one.

2oz Dessert Cups

Starting at $15

Individual single-serve dessert cups filled with your choice of sweet layers — perfect for parties and dessert tables. Flavors and prices may vary.

Assorted Cheesecake

$20

Rich, creamy cheesecake available in a rotating selection of flavors. Ask us what's available for your event date.

Cinnamon Rolls

$12

Soft, pillowy cinnamon rolls baked fresh and finished with your choice of classic glaze, cream cheese frosting, or a seasonal drizzle.

Cookies

Soft, freshly baked cookies in a rotating lineup of irresistible flavors. Each cookie is made to order — perfect for gifting, parties, or treating yourself.

Chocolate Chip

$15

A timeless classic — golden-edged, gooey-centered cookies loaded with rich chocolate chips.

Macadamia

$15

Buttery, chewy cookies studded with creamy macadamia nuts. A luxurious twist on a classic.

Apple Pie

$15

Warm spiced cookies inspired by a classic apple pie — cinnamon, brown sugar, and tender apple pieces in every bite.

Red Velvet w/ Cream Cheese

$15

Soft red velvet cookies with a swirl of tangy cream cheese — rich, velvety, and absolutely indulgent.

Cinnamon Roll

$15

All the cozy flavors of a fresh cinnamon roll baked into a soft, chewy cookie with a sweet glaze drizzle.

VEGAN & GLUTEN FREE Pumpkin Snickerdoodle

$15

Soft and pillowy pumpkin cookies spiced with cinnamon and nutmeg — a fall favorite available year-round.

Snickerdoodle

$15

Classic soft and chewy cookies rolled in cinnamon sugar with that signature tangy cream of tartar flavor.

M&M

$15

Soft, chewy cookies loaded with colorful M&Ms. A crowd-pleasing treat that's always a hit.

Fruity Pebbles

$15

Fun, colorful cookies packed with Fruity Pebbles cereal for a sweet, nostalgic crunch in every bite.

Lemon Crinkle

$15

Bright and zesty lemon cookies with a crinkled powdered sugar coating — light, tangy, and refreshing.

Sugar Cookie

$15

A soft, buttery sugar cookie with a perfectly crisp edge and a melt-in-your-mouth center. Simple and perfect.

Double Chocolate

$15

For the true chocolate lover — a rich, fudgy chocolate cookie loaded with extra chocolate chips.

Monster

$15

A loaded cookie packed with oats, peanut butter, chocolate chips, and M&Ms — a little bit of everything in every bite.

Strawberry

$15

Sweet and fruity strawberry cookies bursting with real strawberry flavor — soft, chewy, and perfectly pink.

Cookie Decorating Kits

$25

Everything you need to decorate your own cookies at home — pre-baked sugar cookies, icing, and all the fun extras. Great for kids' parties, date nights, and family activities.

Party Packages

All-in-one dessert spreads perfect for birthdays, showers, and every kind of celebration. Each package is fully customizable to match your theme.

✦

Party Packages are not yet available for direct purchase online. Please fill out our order form and we'll take care of every sweet detail! Submit your order here →

The Classic

Starting at $170

Dozen Cupcakes, 2 Dozen Chocolate Covered Anything, Dozen Dessert Cups & 6" Cake.

The Celebration

Starting at $240

2 Dozen Cupcakes, 3 Dozen Chocolate Covered Anything, Dozen Dessert Cups & 8" Cake.

The Signature

Starting at $335

2 Dozen Cupcakes, 3 Dozen Chocolate Covered Anything, 3 Dozen Dessert Cups & 10" Cake.

The Grand Celebration

Starting at $480

2 Dozen Cupcakes, 3 Dozen Chocolate Covered Anything, 3 Dozen Dessert Cups & 2 Tier Cake (6" & 8").

Flavors & Fillings

Mix and match your favorite cake flavor with any of our delicious fillings.

Cake Flavors

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Red Velvet
  • Lemon
  • Strawberry
  • Funfetti
  • Marble

Fillings

  • Vanilla Buttercream
  • Chocolate Ganache
  • Strawberry Jam
  • Lemon Curd
  • Cream Cheese
  • Nutella
  • Oreo Crumble

Frosting

  • Vanilla Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • Cream Cheese
  • Whipped Cream
  • Fondant

All prices are starting prices and may vary based on design complexity and customization.

Place a Custom Order

The Perfect Story Bakery

7959 Silverton Ave, Suite 1020

San Diego, CA 92126

+1.619.721.9806

Hours

  • MonBy Appointment
  • TueBy Appointment
  • WedBy Appointment
  • Thu01:00 pm – 06:30 pm
  • Fri01:00 pm – 06:30 pm
  • Sat09:00 am – 06:30 pm
  • Sun09:00 am – 06:30 pm
Copyright © 2026 The Perfect Story Bakery - All Rights Reserved